Weather

Has the path of Monday's total solar eclipse moved?

A recalculation of the path of the April 8, 2024 total solar eclipse published in a blog raises concerns about whether communities along the edges of the path will actually see totality,

Posted Updated
Eclipse path, Monday, April 8
By
Tony Rice
, NASA Ambassador
You may have seen news stories late this week noting a "change" in the path of the 2024 eclipse. This appears to have been triggered by a blog post by John Irwin, sharing calculations he made recently which put the path further south by a few hundred feet in places. Some go as far as listing cities that are "no longer in the path" or "lost their eclipse"

The reality is they these areas along the outer edges of the path won't have a very good total experience under any version of the maps. Even the tiny amount of uncertainty in any of these eclipse calculations translates to hundreds of feet or more on these maps. But most importantly, because circles are round.

Eclipse maps are predictions

As we look at a eclipse maps with their lines defining the limits of the path, it's easy to forget that these areas are  fuzzier in reality. Observations in 2017 found those paths to be off prompting improvements in calculations.

Keep in mind that any eclipse calculation is ultimately predictions because there is still a lot even about our own solar system we don't fully understand yet.

When an eclipse begins and ends and whether the Moon will completely cover the Sun creating a total eclipse, ultimately comes down to the size and position of the Sun and the size and position of the Moon.

Like the spaghetti plots that the WRAL weather team shares showing different models predictions of hurricane paths, the different eclipse maps are built from slightly different values for critical variables in the model.  Each has

Irwin's calculations use a slightly larger number for the Sun's size producing an eclipse path closer to 114 miles wide than 115 through much of the country.

Impact to eclipse watchers

If you are heading out to a spot along the path to experience the total solar eclipse, this probably wont impact you much. Best views of the eclipse are from near the center of the path where the period of totality is greatest, up to 4 minutes 20 seconds or more. Along the edges, the experience is mostly of a partial eclipse with totality lasting seconds if at all. This is true of any version of the map.

Keep in mind that totality is seen inside the Moon's elongated 100+ mile wide circular shadow as it moves at up to 1,600 mph across the Earth's surface.  Near the center line, and the center of that circle, totality lasts much longer.  Near the edges only a tiny part of the circle passes over.

NASA's maps

You won't find a last minute update to NASA's maps describing the path of the eclipse. These maps calculated months ago by the Scientific VIsualization Studio at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center using:
  • data on the position of the Sun, Moon, and Earth maintained by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory. There are a lot of versions of this data with different focuses on different planets and time periods.  DE421 used here focuses on accuracy of the Sun, Moon, and Earth in the relatively short time frame of 1900-2050.  Other versions cover 20,000 years or more with far less accuracy.
  • hyper accurate topography of the Moon gathered by the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter mission. Knowing where the hills and valleys on the Moon are improves accuracy of eclipse predictions
  • hyper accurate topography of the Earth gathered via radar by Space Shuttle Endeavor in 2000. Similarly useful in improving the accuracy.

How eclipse maps are created

It all begins with the position of the Earth, Moon, and Sun. Many calculations start with assuming the Sun and Moon are perfect circles, which they are not, and then adjust for the shape. Like the Earth and pretty much any celestial body that rotates on its axis, the Sun and Moon are a bit fatter at the equator.  Astronomers call this "limb correction"

The Moon's surface is not smooth though, so to further improve predictions, the hills and valleys along the limb (the outer edge of that fatter in the middle circle) must be considered. Evidence of those valleys is seen just before totality as the last rays of sunlight pass through them creating an effect known as "Baily's Beads", named for Francis Baily, a British astronomer who first described the effect in 1836.  The last ray of light through the last valley is known as the "diamond ring" phase.

Baily's beads can be seen shining around the left side of the moon just a second before it completely covers the sun. (Heinz-Peter Bader/X00316/Reuters via CNN Newsource)

When looking at past and future eclipses, the calculations get even more complex as variations in the rotation of the Earth must be factored in as ΔT (delta T).

Copyright 2024 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.