Eve Carson search warrants will remain under wraps for now

Eve Carson portrait

Search warrants related to the investigation into Eve Carson's murder must remain under seal, a Superior Court judge ruled Tuesday.

Earlier this month, The Durham Herald-Sun asked a court to make six search warrants related to the University of North Carolina senior's March 5 shooting death publicly available.

Following a hearing Monday on the motion, Judge Allen Baddour wrote in his ruling that the affidavits contain description and details about the case that could lead to the identification of confidential informants.

"Both confidential informants have been threatened (by persons other than the defendant or co-defendant) and both feel that their safety is at risk and that risk would be increased if their identities were widely known," he wrote.

Baddour also set a new hearing date on the matter for June 27 to determine whether the documents could be released then. Orange County District Attorney Jim Woodall had asked the court Monday that they remain under seal for 60 more days.

Demario James Atwater, 21, and Laurence Alvin Lovette Jr., 17, are each charged with first-degree murder in Carson's death. Police found the 22-year-old's body about a half-mile from the UNC campus while responding to reports of gunfire.

Baddour said he considered releasing parts of the warrants, but rejected doing so because disclosing even part of the warrants and the inventories of items seized would interfere with the investigation.

He also rejected redacting portions of the warrant – an alternative that the Herald-Sun's attorneys proposed on Monday – saying it would be necessary to redact "such a significant portion of the documents so as to render the exercise meaningless."

"The public has a right to information in criminal proceedings, but not in this specific case at this specific time when it interferes with the public’s interest in the investigation of crime, or the defendant’s right (and public’s right, for that matter) to a fair process, free from undue prejudice," Baddour wrote.

Share:
Add to del.icio.us del.icio.us    Add to Digg Digg    Add to Google Google    Add to Yahoo! Yahoo!    Add to facebookfacebook   Add to StumbleUpon StumbleUpon    Add to Reddit Reddit

33 Comments


Golo

Welcome to GOLO, where WRAL.com visitors can comment on stories and create profile pages, blogs and photo galleries.

You must be a registered WRAL.com user to use these tools. Click here to register or log in.

View Comments View Comments

Ask Anything
  1. Cary police K-9 handler Jeremy Burgin and dog, Max
    10 questions with Cary police K-9 Handler Jeremy Burgin

    K-9 Handler Jeremy Burgin answers your questions about training his dog Max, bullet-proof vests for dogs ...

  2. Dr. June Atkinson
    10 questions with State Schools Superintendent June Atkinson

    The state's schools chief answers your questions about funding for schools, seatbelts in buses ...

  3. Harold Weinbrecht
    10 questions with Cary Mayor Harold Weinbrecht

    Harold Weinbrecht answers your questions about the town's reputation, annexations, growth ...

Multimedia
  1. IMG_3715.jpg
    GOLO 1 Year Anniversary Party

  2. BET AWARDS 2008 Press Room
    Campaign Trail Photos of the Week

    View photos from the past week on the campaign trail from AP photographers around the country.

  3. Pumping gas / gas pump generic
    Gas Prices across the nation

    See the cost of gasoline in all 50 states, as reported by the Associated Press.

  4. usyschamp062508
    Southern Regional Soccer championships

    Championship games were held Wednesday, June 25, at the Southern Regional soccer tournament in Raleigh and Wilson.

  5. Grocery Cart Tracker- Special 5OYS Edition
    Warehouse cheaper than grocers

    Monica Laliberte compares the prices of fourteen common items at warehouse stores and regular grocery stores.